Title: The Girl on the Train
Author: Paula Hawkins
Page Count: 323 pages
Genre: Psychological Suspense, Crime Fiction
Tone: Compelling, Tense, Disturbing
Rachel sees the same couple breakfasting on their deck each morning as she passes by in her commuter train. She thinks their life looks perfect until, one day, she sees something shocking. The train moves on immediately, but she can’t keep it to herself and informs the police. Has she done more harm than good?
These book discussion questions are highly detailed and will ruin plot points if you have not read the book.
The Library is happy to share these original questions for your use. If reproducing, please credit with the following statement: 2017 Mount Prospect Public Library. All rights reserved. Used with Permission.
1. The Girl on the Train debuted as #1 on the NYT Bestseller Fiction List and has continued to break sales and library checkout records. In your opinion, what is it about this book that captured the interest of millions of readers worldwide?
2. Many complain that Rachel is unlikable. Do you agree? How important to your enjoyment of a book depends on whether you like a main character? Does your response differ if the difficult character is male or female?
3. Others maintain that relatability is more important than likability. Is Rachel relatable to you? Do you understand her choices? Do you care what happens to her?
4. Many psychological thrillers of recent years incorporate uncertain memory as a major factor. What is it about amnesia or compromised memory that works so well in these stories?
5. Do you react differently to Rachel’s memory issues because they are her own fault?
6. Would the story have worked without Rachel’s multiple personal issues: a ‘stable’ commuter who notices out the window, for instance?
7. It has been suggested that Rachel is symbolic of our voyeuristic tendencies – both as individuals and as a society. Is this fair?
8. What does Rachel gain from her involvement in the investigation? What does it cost her?
9. Was the choice to use multiple perspectives effective? One review complained that the lack of distinction confuses the reader. How would you respond?
10. Contrast the life Rachel imagined for Jess with what we learn of Megan’s reality. What else do we gain from Megan’s perspective?
11. Anna’s voice isn’t introduced until a third of the way into the book. Did it surprise you? Throw you off? How distinct is her voice?
12. Speaking of voice, why are only female characters chosen for point of view?
13. Are there characters (main or secondary) that you trusted or knew right away not to trust?
14. Did you ever believe Rachel had something to do with Megan’s disappearance? Did she?
15. Would this story play out the same in a US setting, or are the UK elements essential?
16. Hawkins has said that “the set-up is often the fun part” with scenarios and red herrings, but it is “a really hard thing to make that final act a convincing ending.” How’d she do?
17. What becomes of the surviving characters? What kinds of lives do they lead in future?
18. Would you characterize this as a cynical book? Is there any hope or positivity? Does that matter?
19. What, if anything, is Hawkins trying to say about marriage/relationships?
20. How are children or pregnancy (or barrenness) catalysts for much of the action? Is this intended to be cultural commentary?
21. The theme of self-sabotage is well explored through several characters. Is there any examination of recovery or redemption?
22. What did you think of Hawkins’ writing? Did you respond positively to her style, her prose, and/or her pacing?
23. Early in movie talks, Hawkins commented that she had no idea who should be cast as Rachel, as she’s specifically described as unattractive. The finished adaptation stars Emily Blunt, whom Hawkins publicly endorsed as excellent in the role. Does casting a beautiful woman change the tenor of the story?
24. Having “Girl” in the title has become shorthand to identify a specific type of psychological thriller. Is it problematic that a 32-year-old, divorced, hard-drinking woman is labelled this way? For contrast, consider the parallel The Boy on the Train. Why do you think this is so?
25. How would you characterize your experience of reading The Girl on the Train? Did you approach it as a whodunit? Would you describe it as a fun read?
Want help with your book discussion group? Check out tips, advice, and all the ways the Library can help support your group!
Paula Hawkins: By the Book via New York Times Book Review
Paula Hawkins: The Woman Behind The Girl on the Train via The Guardian
Interview on NPR: All Things Considered (audio or transcript)
BookPage feature on Paula Hawkins
LitLovers discussion guide
Three perspectives on the book’s settings: The Book Trail, shmoop, and a composite map
Hawkins’ next book, Into the Water, announced
The Pocket Wife
by Susan Crawford
Behind Her Eyes
by Sarah Pinborough
by Michael Robotham